Questions & Answers: Implementation of New Rules Regarding Grooves
What is the plan for implementing the new groove rules at
USGA championships?
The new rules regarding grooves will be adopted as a
condition of competition for the 2010 U.S. Open, U.S. Women’s Open and U.S.
Senior Open, as well as sectional (final stage) qualifying events for these
three championships. The condition will not be in effect at local (first
stage) qualifying events for the 2010 U.S. Open or at any of the USGA’s national
championships and team competitions that are contested by amateurs only. There
is no local (first stage) qualifying stage for the U.S Women’s Open or U.S.
Senior Open.
The USGA will adopt the condition of competition for U.S.
Open local qualifying beginning in 2011 and for the national championships and
team competitions it conducts for amateur players no later than 2014, as
originally announced.
The full text of the condition of competition appears at the
end of this document.
What guidance does the USGA offer to state and regional
golf associations or clubs regarding adoption of the condition of competition
for local or regional competitions?
Although the condition of competition will be included in
the Rules of Golf as of January 1, 2010 for committees to adopt, the USGA plans
to implement the condition over a period of several years, beginning in 2010
with the U.S. Open, U.S. Women’s Open, and U.S. Senior Open and their sectional
(final stage) qualifying events. As originally announced, the USGA intends to
adopt the condition for the championships and team events it conducts for
amateur players no later than 2014. The USGA recommends that state and regional
associations and clubs implement the condition in accordance with this general
time frame.However, if the condition is implemented in 2014, or sooner,
it is the recommendation of the USGA that this condition should be adopted only
for competitions involving expert players.
What are the basics of the new
groove regulations?
Although the complete technical specifications of the new groove
requirements are more detailed, the following statements summarize the key
changes:
The volume of grooves is reduced.
Groove edge
sharpness is reduced for
clubs with lofts greater than or equal to 25 degrees.
A common misconception is that “V” shaped grooves will be required under
the new specifications and that “U” shaped grooves will no longer be
allowed. This is not the case. However, any “U” shaped groove must conform
to the new specifications for both cross sectional area/spacing and edge
radius.
The changes are designed to reduce spin on shots played from the rough
by highly skilled golfers, and thereby restore the challenge of shots played from
the rough to the green. This should result in an increase in the importance of
driving accuracy.
What
is the effect of the new grooves on the average player?
The changes are expected to have little
impact on the general golfing population for three reasons. First, USGA research
shows that average golfers playing from the rough hit the green in regulation only
13 percent of the time. Second, two-thirds of golf balls
sold are surlyn-covered balls which show little spin effect from different
groove designs. Finally, all existing clubs that presently conform to the rules will
continue to be deemed conforming through at least 2024, when the condition of
competition is expected to become a permanent equipment specification. Consumer research shows that only 2 percent of irons are in use for more than 15
years.
How
does a player determine if a club or set of clubs conforms to the new
specifications?
The USGA is developing a database that will
help players determine if clubs conform to the new specifications, provided the
club or set of clubs has not been altered and is “as manufactured.” The database will list all irons and wedges, as
well as hybrids and fairway woods with lofts greater than or equal to 25
degrees, that have been evaluated for conformance to the 2010 Rules of Golf.
The database will be available on the USGA’s Web site (www.usga.org) by late October 2009.
Alternately, a player may contact the
manufacturer of the clubs for information regarding conformance to the 2010 Rules
of Golf.
What
is the protocol if a player needs to determine the conformity of a club, or the
conformity of the club’s grooves is called into question during a sectional
qualifying event for the U.S. Open, U.S. Women’s Open or U.S. Senior Open?
Players are strongly encouraged to resolve
any questions about club conformance prior to arriving on site for any qualifying
event.
As is the case with any question on the Rules
of Golf or equipment, any player who is concerned about the conformity of
grooves should find the USGA official in charge of the qualifying event as soon
as practicable. The first step will be to determine the make and model of the
club in question and whether the club has been included in the USGA database of
clubs. If the club is listed in the database as meeting the 2010 groove
specifications, has not been altered, and there are no other extenuating
circumstances or other evidence of non-conformance, the club will be assumed to
conform. If the club is not listed as such in the database and a determination
cannot be made immediately, the player may choose to play with the
club but risks disqualification if a determination is subsequently made that
the club does not conform. Field testing
will not be performed at local (first stage) or sectional (final stage)
qualifying sites.
If another player calls into question the
conformity of a player’s grooves, as with any question that arises during the
competition, the USGA Rules Committee will take all pertinent facts into
consideration in evaluating the situation, and the above procedure will apply
if necessary. The decision of the USGA Rules Committee will be final.
What
is the protocol if a player needs to determine the conformity of a club, or the
conformity of the club’s grooves is called into question during the U.S. Open, U.S.
Women’s Open or U.S. Senior Open?
Players are strongly encouraged to resolve
any questions about club conformance prior to arriving on site for any championship.
Once on site, a player who is concerned about
the conformity of grooves should alert a member of the USGA’s Rules Committee as
soon as practicable, as is the case with any question on the Rules of Golf or
equipment. The first step will be to determine the make and model of the club in
question and whether the club has been included in the USGA database of clubs.
If the club is listed in the database, has not been altered, and there are no
other extenuating circumstances or other evidence of non-conformance, the club
will be assumed to conform.
If a club does not appear in the database or
if the club has been altered, officials on site will have the ability to
conduct a field test to determine conformance. The field test that the USGA has
developed will take less than 10 minutes for a club and no more than 30 minutes
for a set of clubs.
If another player calls into question the
conformity of a player’s grooves, as with any question that arises during the
competition, the USGA Rules Committee will take all pertinent facts into
consideration in evaluating the situation, and the above procedure will apply
if necessary. The decision of the USGA Rules Committee will be final.
What
are the plans of other major golf organizations with respect to the new
condition of competition?
The PGA Tour (including
the Champions and Nationwide Tours), European PGA Tour and other members of the
International Federation of PGA Tours, as well as the LPGA, intend to adopt
this condition of competition at their tournaments beginning Jan. 1, 2010. The
PGA of America and Augusta National Golf Club intend to adopt this condition of
competition at the PGA Championship and Masters Tournament, respectively, in
2010.
What has been the timeline in
making the change?
Work on this subject has been ongoing at the USGA and R&A for many
years. The following is an outline of key dates in the process, as well as
future milestones:
2005 USGA and R&A
announce they will be studying the effect of grooves.
August
2006 USGA publishes
first of two major research reports on groove
February
2007 USGA
and R&A propose limits on groove volume and edge radius,
seeking
feedback from manufacturers.
August 2008 USGA and R&A adopt a revised proposal,
incorporating manufacturer comments.
January
1, 2010 All new clubs submitted to
USGA for approval must conform to new
specifications.
PGA Tour, major
championships and international federation tours will adopt the rule as an
“expert” condition of competition.
Manufacturers are
allowed to produce existing clubs and exhaust inventory until the end of 2010.
2014 USGA
and R&A have announced they will implement condition of competition at
expert amateur competitions. Other golf
organizations (for example, state and regional associations) are expected to
follow the USGA and R&A timeline for their expert competitions.
2024 Earliest date the
condition of competition will become a permanent
equipment
specification in the Rules of Golf.
4-1/1 Condition
Requiring Clubs Conforming with Groove and Punch Mark Specifications Effective
January 1, 2010
A
Committee that wishes to limit players to clubs manufactured with grooves
and/or punch marks that conform to all aspects of the Rules of Golf
that are effective from January 1, 2010 may adopt the condition of competition
detailed below.
Between
January 1, 2010 and January 1, 2014, it is recommended that this condition of
competition be adopted only for competitions involving the highest level of
expert player. After January 1, 2014, this condition of competition may
be adopted more widely (e.g., at the highest level of amateur golf), but it is
recommended only for competitions involving expert players.
"The player’s clubs must conform to the groove and punch mark
specifications in the Rules of Golf that are effective from January 1, 2010.
*PENALTY FOR CARRYING, BUT NOT MAKING STROKE WITH, CLUB OR CLUBS IN
BREACH OF CONDITION: Match play - At the conclusion of the hole at which the breach is
discovered, the state of the match is adjusted by deducting one hole for each
hole at which a breach occurred; maximum deduction per round - Two holes. Stroke play - Two strokes for each hole at which any breach occurred;
maximum penalty per round - Four strokes. Match or stroke play - In the event of a breach between the play of two
holes, the penalty applies to the next hole. Bogey and par competitions - See Note 1 to Rule 32-1a. Stableford competitions - See Note 1 to Rule 32-1b.
*Any club or clubs carried in breach of this condition must be declared
out of play by the player to his opponent in match play or his marker or
a fellow-competitor in stroke play immediately upon discovery that a
breach has occurred. If the player fails to do so, he is disqualified.
PENALTY FOR MAKING STROKE WITH CLUB IN BREACH OF CONDITION:
Disqualification.
Exception:
Clubs manufactured before March 31, 1990 that meet the criteria of USGA
Decision USGA/4-1/100, such as the Ping Eye 2 irons, will be permitted for play
when the above Condition Requiring Clubs Conforming with Groove and Punch Mark
Specifications Effective January 1, 2010 is in effect.”
